Have you been arrested for a crime you had no intention of committing? If so, you’re probably wondering about what that could mean for the case against you. Here’s what you need to know.
The Role of Criminal Intent
The elements of most criminal offenses fall into two categories: criminal intent (mens rea) and criminal act (actus reus). Many crimes have a mens rea element to avoid prosecuting individuals who may have inadvertently committed an actus reus without any intent to commit a crime. For example, a person who inadvertently knocks someone over should not face prosecution for battery because they did not intend to offensively touch or injure that individual. Thus, criminal intent prevents individuals from facing prosecution for genuine accidents or incidents caused by ordinary carelessness.
Different crimes may have different degrees of required criminal intent. Common types of criminal intent include:
- Intentionally or willfully: A person acts intentionally or willfully when they design their conduct to commit the criminal act.
- Knowingly: A person acts knowingly when they understand that their conduct will or likely will result in a criminal act, even if they do not specifically intend to commit a criminal act.
- Recklessly or with gross negligence: A person acts recklessly when they consciously disregard a substantial risk that their conduct will result in a criminal act.
Crimes Without Criminal Intent
Some crimes do not have a criminal intent element. The law considers such offenses as “strict liability” offenses. One example of a strict liability offense includes distributing or delivering drugs that result in a user’s death. Another example includes statutory rape, as a person can commit the offense regardless of their knowledge of the victim’s age or their intent to commit a criminal offense. Strict liability offenses include crimes legislators and the public consider so severe that criminal liability should attach regardless of the defendant’s intent.
Legal Defenses to Crimes Committed without Intent
Common defense strategies used to argue a lack of criminal intent include:
- Insufficiency of evidence of intent: A defendant may argue that the prosecution’s evidence fails to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant acted with the statutorily required intent.
- Mistake of fact: Defendants may assert that they made a mistake of fact that negates criminal intent. For example, a defendant may argue that they took an item they genuinely believed belonged to them.
- Entrapment: An entrapment defense alleges that law enforcement induced the defendant to commit a crime they otherwise had no intent to commit.
- Duress: A defendant may assert a duress defense, claiming they acted due to coercion or threats from others.
- Necessity: A necessity defense argues that a person committed something that would constitute a criminal act to prevent a greater crime or harm.
Potential Legal Consequences and How to Respond
Even if you did not intend to commit a crime, you can still face legal consequences for criminal prosecution, depending on your charges. For example, charges for strict liability offenses will not involve any questions about your intent. When your charges have a mens rea element, prosecutors may seek to prove intent through circumstantial evidence that allows a jury to infer intent, such as acts after the crime that suggest a guilty conscience.
When prosecutors charge you with a crime you did not intend to commit, steps you can take to protect your legal rights and options include:
- Exercise your right to remain silent and decline to speak to the police or answer questions until you’ve spoken to a criminal defense attorney.
- Refrain from actions suggesting a guilty conscience, such as hiding or destroying evidence or attempting to talk to alleged victims or witnesses.
- Contact a criminal defense lawyer as soon as possible to discuss potential defense strategies based on your lack of criminal intent.
Contact a Criminal Defense Attorney Today
If you’ve been arrested for a crime you did not intend to commit, an experienced criminal defense lawyer can help you pursue a tailored legal strategy to secure a favorable resolution to your charges. Contact Hancock Law Firm today for a confidential consultation to discuss your legal options for defending yourself against your charges.