It’s common for people who have injured and even killed others to invoke self-defense, but how effective is this argument? Understanding when the law allows one to claim self-defense, and when a justified action instead becomes a criminal charge, is critical to your case.
Did you defend yourself from harm and now find yourself with criminal charges? By working with a Carteret County criminal defense attorney, you can explore all legal options, including self-defense. Hancock Law Firm, PLLC explains what you need to know.
What is Self-Defense in North Carolina?
Self-defense is the legal right to protect yourself when you are facing the imminent threat of harm. There is a similar right to defend others who are also threatened. Self-defense allows a would-be victim to take reasonable steps to avoid injury or death.
But there are some important caveats associated with self-defense. To successfully invoke this justification, a defendant must prove the following:
- The defendant was imminently threatened: This means a threat of serious bodily harm or death.
- The belief about the threat was reasonable: The circumstances must indicate that the defendant’s belief about an imminent threat was reasonable.
- The force used was proportional: The defendant’s use of force in defending themself must be proportional to the threat. Excessive force may invalidate any self-defense argument.
- There was no duty to retreat: In general, there is no duty to retreat in North Carolina, and this arises more specifically in “stand your ground” situations (see below).
- There was no initial aggression: The defendant cannot argue self-defense if either they provoked the situation or escalated it to the point of violence.
North Carolina has two important self-defense laws that defendants should know about: Stand Your Ground and the Castle Doctrine. A knowledgeable Carteret County criminal defense lawyer can explain them.
What is Stand Your Ground?
Many states, including North Carolina, have enacted “stand your ground” laws. “Stand your ground” means that a person does not have to retreat before using force to defend themself. However, the person must have the lawful right to be present where they used force.
Stand your ground allows the use of force, even deadly force, to defend oneself from harm. There are a few specific requirements the defendant must prove:
- The defendant was protecting themself or others from imminent harm
- The defendant reasonably believed that force was necessary to prevent death, serious bodily injury, or a forcible felony (e.g. kidnapping)
- The defendant was in a location where they had a legal right to be
What is the Castle Doctrine?
The Castle Doctrine allows a person in Carteret County to use force (including deadly force) to protect themself, their home or residence, their vehicle, and their workplace. The person must have a reasonable belief that there is an imminent threat of harm.
This rule does not allow a person to use deadly force if they were the initial aggressor or they could have safely retreated from the danger. It also creates two presumptions that prosecutors may rebut. Those presumptions are:
- That the lawful occupant of a home, residence, vehicle, or workplace is presumed to have a reasonable fear of imminent death or serious bodily harm (to themself or others)
- That the person who unlawfully entered the home, residence, vehicle, or workplace is presumed to have done so with the intent to commit an act of force or violence
In order to rebut these presumptions, prosecutors can only use one of five specific exceptions found in the Castle Doctrine statute:
- The “intruder” had a legal right to be in the home, residence, vehicle, or workplace
- The person whom the “intruder” tried to remove was a child or grandchild over whom the “intruder” had lawful custody or guardianship
- The defendant – the one who used force – was engaged in criminal activity at the time
- The “intruder” is a law enforcement officer or bail bondsman lawfully performing their duties
- The “intruder” discontinued all efforts to enter the home, residence, vehicle, or workplace and also left said place
Differences Between Stand Your Ground and Castle Doctrine
Also they are similar, these two forms of self-defense have some notable differences between them. They include:
- Stand Your Ground authorizes force in any place where the defendant has a right to be, not just in the places listed under the Castle Doctrine
- Unlike the Castle Doctrine, Stand Your Ground does not create presumptions of death and bodily harm
- Castle Doctrine does not include a prohibition on excessive force, while Stand Your Ground does
When “Self-Defense” Becomes Criminal
These are some realistic case examples of when an otherwise justified act of self-defense can turn into a criminal charge:
- Using disproportionate force: The proportionality of force to the threat is a serious consideration that judges and prosecutors will evaluate. Put simply, a defendant cannot use more force than is reasonably necessary to defuse the threat.
- Using deadly force: More specifically, the use of deadly force has often been a sticking point in self-defense cases. If someone is committing vandalism to your vehicle, you cannot shoot and kill them. Judges and prosecutors carefully review deadly force cases for compliance with the law.
- The belief of imminent harm was not reasonable: A person can claim that they believed the person they killed was about to injure or kill them. But sometimes this belief is not founded. Prosecutors evaluate the totality of the circumstances to consider the reasonableness issue.
- Starting a fight: If the defendant is the one who started the fight and later tries to invoke self-defense, there is a good chance the argument will fail. For example, if you shove someone at the bar, they shove back, and then you punch them, this is likely not self-defense.
- The threat ended when force or violence was used: Once the danger is over, the right to self-defense generally goes away because it does not permit retaliation. This is a complicated issue, however. What if the aggressor went away but then came back, or threatened to?
Talk to Our Dedicated Criminal Defense Attorney
North Carolina laws allow a defendant to argue one of several forms of self-defense. But understanding the nuances of the two above doctrines is critical. Without a strong legal strategy, your self-defense argument could fail and leave you facing serious jail time.
If you used force to defend yourself or others from harm, and were then charged with a crime, connect with Hancock Law Firm, PLLC to explore your self-defense options. We are proud to serve clients in Carteret County and elsewhere in North Carolina. Get in touch with us today.